When Renting Makes Sense
Rent when size changes. String instruments come in fractional sizes and a growing child may move up more than once. Renting turns that from a series of purchases into an exchange.
Rent when the instrument is expensive and the commitment is unproven. Band instruments in particular — a decent student trumpet, flute, or clarinet is a real purchase, and rent-to-own programs at local retailers let you apply payments toward ownership if the student sticks with it.
Rent when maintenance matters. Rental agreements usually include repair coverage, which is worth more than it sounds for an instrument riding in a school backpack.
When Buying Makes Sense
Buy guitars. A solid beginner acoustic or electric runs well under what a year of rental would cost, and guitars do not need to be replaced as a child grows the way a violin does. Get the smaller body size for a younger student rather than renting a full size.
Buy keyboards, with one caveat: get 88 weighted keys if you can, or at least 61 touch-sensitive ones. A cheap unweighted keyboard builds the wrong hand strength and students hit a ceiling on it within a year.
Buy percussion practice equipment. A practice pad and a pair of sticks costs very little and is what most of the early drum work happens on anyway. A full kit can wait until the student has proven they will use it.
Where to Rent and Buy in the Omaha Metro
Local music retailers such as Dietze Music carry rental programs for band and orchestra instruments and can size a student in person, which is worth the trip for anything with fractional sizing. School band programs often have their own rental partnerships too — ask the band director before signing anything.
For guitars and keyboards, buying locally is usually worth a small premium over online. A shop will set up a guitar properly before it leaves, and a badly set-up guitar is genuinely painful to play — which is a common and avoidable reason beginners quit.
Whatever you do, avoid the very cheapest instrument-shaped objects sold in big-box and online marketplaces. They often cannot hold tune or produce a correct tone, and a student who cannot get a decent sound out of an instrument concludes the problem is them.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Should I rent or buy my child first instrument?
- Rent anything large, expensive, or size-dependent — violin, cello, and most band instruments. Buy anything small and size-stable, like a beginner guitar, a keyboard, or a drum practice pad. Renting protects you when the instrument has to change size or when the commitment is still unproven.
- Do I need an instrument before the first lesson?
- No. Come to the first lesson first. Your teacher can advise on size, type, and budget for your specific student, and some teachers have loaner instruments available for the first few weeks.
- What kind of keyboard should I buy for piano lessons?
- Look for 88 weighted keys if the budget allows, or at minimum 61 touch-sensitive keys. Unweighted keyboards build the wrong hand strength and students outgrow them quickly. This is the one purchase where spending a little more genuinely changes the outcome.
- How much does a beginner instrument cost?
- A decent beginner guitar or keyboard is typically a modest one-time purchase, well under a year of rental. Band and orchestra instruments are substantially more, which is exactly why renting them is the norm.
- Is it worth buying a used instrument?
- Often yes, if it is checked over first. Guitars and keyboards hold up well. For band and string instruments, have a shop or your teacher inspect it before you buy — a cheap instrument needing a costly repair is not a bargain.
Find a Studio Near You
Start Your Music Journey Today
Join hundreds of students learning at Adkins Music. Sign up in 30 seconds — no commitment required.
Enroll Now